West Coast Eagles (8-4, 4th)
What's gone right: The Eagles haven't rested on the laurels of a 2018 premiership, continuing to put themselves in the framework to contend for back-to-back flags. The Eagles remain in the top four after the first 12 games of the season, and without truly setting the world on fire, either. When they truly get going, it will be a daunting prospect for those clubs above them on the table. That includes Collingwood and GWS, who the Eagles both disposed of with ease early on in the season.
What's gone wrong: Similar to Collingwood, you feel like West Coast has remained in first gear for a large majority of the season so far. Since their strong defeats of the Magpies and the Giants in rounds two and three, the Eagles have been on the receiving end of some significant beltings; namely from the likes of Port Adelaide, Sydney and Geelong. Quite simply, West Coast has been far too inconsistent this season, and the gap between their best and their worst has been concerning for Adam Simpson's side.
Best and fairest: A swarm of Eagles are well and truly in contention for the John Worsfold Medal. Andrew Gaff has reminded everyone of his quality since his return from suspension, averaging over 32 disposals and providing some class in the midfield. Norm Smith Medalist Luke Shuey has also been on song, being a consistent part of the Eagles' outfit and keeping their midfield ticking over as well. But skipper Shannon Hurn has been another great contributor and could very well be the favourite to take out the best and fairest. Hurn has been fantastic coming out of the Eagles' defence, averaging 26 possessions and being a valuable and efficient cog in the Eagles' outfit.
Season grade: B
The Eagles have managed to remain in contention for the flag after winning it last year, but they certainly haven't hit the lofty heights or standards that they set in 2018 either. The Eagles have managed to go about winning some of their matches without being overly convincing. Maybe the sign of a good team is winning those type of matches, but much more will be needed from them if they are to win their second consecutive premiership.
