Collingwood (9-3, 2nd)
What's gone right: The Pies have well and truly shown that last season's efforts weren't a one-off by any stretch of the imagination. Thirsty for that premiership and determined to succeed, Collingwood has shown why they are every chance to be there at the very end of September. Their talent-stacked midfield has been immense, with Adam Treloar and Scott Pendlebury showcasing their brilliance as consistently as always, while the emergence of Darcy Moore as a mainstay in the Collingwood defence has them primed for a finals series assault.
What's gone wrong: As good as Collingwood has been, there is still work to be done. In some games this year, it's seemed as if the Magpies haven't moved out of first gear, and still have a lot more in their ammunition. With early season losses to Geelong and West Coast - both genuine premiership competitors as things stand - questions linger on whether the Pies can get it done in the big games against the best teams. They have already beaten Brisbane, Richmond and Port Adelaide, but the Cats look like the team to beat as things stand. Back-to-back games against the Eagles and the Giants in July could be a good indicator of where Collingwood stands this season.
Best and fairest: With a luxury of A-graders in their ranks, Brodie Grundy has risen above all this season. The Magpies' ruckman has been immense this season, covering ground and picking up his fair share of the ball as well. The prospect of a Brownlow around the 25-year-old's neck would be well deserved as things stand, and you certainly wouldn't rule Grundy out by any means.
Season grade: B
Having done so much right, Collingwood has mostly matched the expectations placed on them for this year. You feel like they have another level to go to, which will be needed against some of their main premiership threats. If they can reach that level, though, then the Black and White army might be in for some happier days come September.
