Some of the AFL's best footballers have come from the 2016 AFL Draft, producing 15 All-Australian selections, 12 club Best & Fairests and 14 Premierships.

Unlike many draft classes, the top players from 2016 didn't come from the early parts of the draft, rather being unearthed in the later rounds, defying expectations as they paved their path to stardom.

From the original top 10, only one player has earned an All-Australian selection, and two were named Best & Fairest.

Now a decade on, we re-draft the first 10 picks, factoring in club needs, the players' early career success, and which players would impact the most on winning now.

With the benefit of hindsight, it's safe to say several clubs would have made vastly different decisions.

For context, here were the original first 10 selections in the 2016 AFL Draft:

  1. Andrew McGrath (Essendon)
  2. Tim Taranto (GWS)
  3. Hugh McCluggage (Brisbane)
  4. Ben Ainsworth (Gold Coast)
  5. Will Setterfield (GWS)
  6. Sam Petrevski-Seton (Carlton)
  7. Jack Scrimshaw (Gold Coast)
  8. Griffin Logue (Fremantle)
  9. Will Brodie (Gold Coast)
  10. Jack Bowes (Gold Coast)

Pick 2: Hugh McCluggage (+1) - GWS Giants

The Giants selected tall midfielder Tim Taranto with the second pick in the 2016 AFL draft following a heartbreaking Preliminary Final defeat to the Western Bulldogs.

GWS wanted a player who could make an immediate finals impact, with Taranto playing in 14 matches in his first year, including the Preliminary Final loss to Richmond.

Taranto was a positive selection for the Giants, playing as a productive goalkicking midfielder, but a better selection was on the board that the club would select in hindsight: Hugh McCluggage.

McCluggage, a similar build to Taranto, plays as more of an outside midfielder/wingman with a rifling kick.

For Brisbane, McCluggage is a 3x Premiership player, 4x member of the AA40 and an All-Australian in 2025.

McCluggage would have perfectly complemented the midfield group of Dylan Shiel, Josh Kelly and Stephen Coniglio through the early parts of his career and would be a great leader for the current iteration of the Giants.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION