The 2015 AFL draft has some of the most accomplished players in the league, producing 14 All-Australians, 17 club Best & Fairests, 3 Coleman Medals, 2 AFLCA Player of the Year awards and 15 Premierships.

Many players from the original top 10 had stellar AFL careers, with the likes of Jacob Weitering, Clayton Oliver, Callum Mills, Darcy Parish and Harry McKay carving out All-Australian level seasons throughout their illustrious careers.

The 2015 draft extended far beyond the first round, with some of the biggest draft day steals in recent history found in the depths of the fourth round, producing some of the most courageous captains in the AFL.

Now a decade on, we re-draft the first 10 picks, factoring in club needs, the players' early career success, and which players would impact the most to winning now.

With the benefit of hindsight, it's safe to say several clubs would have made vastly different decisions.

For context, here were the original first 10 selections in the 2015 AFL Draft:

  1. Jacob Weitering (Carlton)
  2. Josh Schache (Brisbane)
  3. Callum Mills (Sydney acad.)
  4. Clayton Oliver (Melbourne)
  5. Darcy Parish (Essendon)
  6. Aaron Francis (Essendon)
  7. Jacob Hopper (GWS acad.)
  8. Callum Ah Chee (Gold Coast)
  9. Sam Weideman (Melbourne)
  10. Harry McKay (Carlton)
Next

1. Pick 1: Clayton Oliver (+3) - Carlton

With the first pick in the 2015 AFL draft, the Blues originally selected star key defender Jacob Weitering, who handled the pressure maturely, bursting onto the scene as a consistent staple in defence for Carlton.

Weitering has been a good selection for the Blues, winning multiple John Nicholls Medals and being selected to the All-Australian side in 2024.

Weitering was not the best choice at this selection, as in a re-draft the Blues take original Pick 4, Clayton Oliver.

Oliver was an immediate star for Melbourne from debut, winning the Demons' club Best & Fairest in just his second season and earning his first All-Australian in 2018.

Through Carlton's rebuilding period, Patrick Cripps was crying out for some midfield support, putting the Blues' engine room on his back every week.

Oliver would have provided exactly that, with the two-time AFLCA Player of the Year (2021 and 2022) forming a formidable midfield duo that could have dominated for years.

Next

JOIN THE DISCUSSION