AFL Editorial and Opinion

Ranking every AFL club’s backline 18-1: Part III

Is your club’s defence part of the league’s upper echelon?

Published by
Zero Hanger

Glorifying the AFL's ball-winners and goalkickers is commonplace across the footballing landscape, but as the age-old adage goes: 'defence wins premierships'.

The club that holds the silverware aloft at the end of a season typically boasts a backline consisting of immovable key defenders, eagle-eyed interceptors and attack-minded flankers.

Last year's grand finalists, for example, each possessed stingy, impregnable defensive units, comprising stars such as Darcy MooreHarris AndrewsBrayden MaynardBrandon StarcevichIsaac Quaynor and Keidean Coleman, among others.

So, taking into account last year's performance, current personnel and injuries, where does each club's defence rank as we prepare to embark on the 2024 season?

We've ranked every AFL club's backline from worst to first. Here are the top six rearguards in the competition.

*Denotes a currently injured player

Adelaide Crows

Core personnel: Nick Murray*, Jordon Butts, Mitchell Hinge, Brodie Smith, Max Michalanney, Josh Worrell, Daniel Curtin, Mark Keane, Elliott Himmelberg, Wayne Milera

Key defender Murray, who suffered an ACL rupture last season, will be absent for the early portion of Adelaide's season in a significant loss. 

However, the Crows possess depth in defence, with the likes of Keane, Himmelberg and Borlase presenting as ample replacements. 

As a whole, the upside of this youthful defensive brigade – particularly the mid-sized Michalanney, promising draftee Curtin and versatile utility Worrell – is enough to have them highly placed entering the new season.

 

Adelaide Crow Max Michalanney (Photo by Sarah Reed/AFL Photos)

 

GWS Giants

Core personnel: Sam Taylor, Connor Idun, Harry Himmelberg, Jack Buckley, Lachie Whitfield, Lachie Ash, Isaac Cumming, Adam Kennedy*

Despite entering last season with one of the more unassuming units in the competition, GWS' defending contingent stood tall for Adam Kingsley, especially during the club's September sojourn.

In particular, star key defender Taylor was typically prolific, as was Idun, who showcased his physicality in one-on-one contests during a break-out campaign.

Buckley and the re-committed Himmelberg were also instrumental in holding down the Giants' fort.

 

Conor Idun

 

Carlton

Core personnel: Jacob Weitering*, Mitch McGovern, Brodie Kemp, Caleb Marchbank, Adam Saad, Sam Docherty, Nic Newman, Zac Williams

Weitering's early absence hurts the Blues, particularly as they prepare to combat Joe Daniher and Tom Lynch across their opening pair of games.

They will, however, be buoyed by the return of a healthy Williams, who hasn't played more than 14 senior games in a season since 2019.

Further, Kemp's emergence as a taller stopper last season paid dividends, and the club's match committee will hope the 22-year-old resumes his ascension in 2024.

Around them, the likes of Saad, Newman and Docherty, when down back, will add plenty, and if Marchbank and McGovern can stay fit or in form, Michael Voss will have plenty of weapons at his disposal.

 

MELBOURNE, AUSTRALIA - MAY 05: Jacob Weitering of the Blues spoils a mark by Eric Hipwood of the Lions during the round eight AFL match between Carlton Blues and Brisbane Lions at Marvel Stadium, on May 05, 2023, in Melbourne, Australia. (Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

 

Melbourne

Core personnel: Steven May, Jake Lever, Adam Tomlinson, Trent Rivers, Christian Salem, Judd McVee, Jake Bowey

In May and Lever, Melbourne has access to one of the league's finest full-backs, as well as one of its most potent interceptors.

With aerial threats covered, the likes of McVee and, when selected, Bowey can get to work sending the footy forward, with the ever-impressive Rivers providing aid in the air and on the ground.

When needed, Tomlinson can perform a role admirably, with the former Giant holding no fear when it comes to wrangling the game's biggest goalsquare gorillas.

MELBOURNE, AUSTRALIA - SEPTEMBER 02: Steven May of the Demons in action during the 2022 AFL Second Qualifying Final match between the Melbourne Demons and the Sydney Swans at the Melbourne Cricket Ground on September 2, 2022 in Melbourne, Australia. (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

Collingwood

Core personnel: Darcy Moore, Brayden Maynard, Isaac Quaynor, Nathan Murphy*, Jeremy Howe, Oleg Markov, John Noble

In the air, on the ground, flying backward or sending the footy forward, Collingwood is served by a near-complete unit of players who know their roles to a tee.

With skipper Darcy Moore leading the line, the Pies are routinely in good shape, and with the likes of Murphy, Maynard, Quaynor and high-flyer Jeremy Howe around him, opposition sides are better served moving the ball inside 50 by hand rather than just bombing it long.

When it does eventually hit the deck, the Woods have deadly options, with each of Noble and Markov adept at riffing with teammates, as well as moving it forward at pace.

MELBOURNE, AUSTRALIA - JUNE 25: Darcy Moore, Nathan Murphy and Jack Crisp of the Magpies celebrate winning the round 15 AFL match between Collingwood Magpies and Adelaide Crows at Melbourne Cricket Ground, on June 25, 2023, in Melbourne, Australia. (Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

Brisbane Lions

Core personnel: Harris Andrews, Brandon Starcevich, Tom Doedee*, Jack Payne, Keidean Coleman, Conor McKenna, Darcy Wilmot, Dayne Zorko, Ryan Lester

Coleman's continued progression this season is a storyline worth monitoring. The second-place finisher in last year's Norm Smith Medal count is poised to transition to bonafide stardom, having already showcased his mesmerising foot skills and speed exiting defensive 50.

Further aiding Brisbane's defensive cause this season – once he's healthy – is ex-Adelaide recruit Tom Doedee, who continues his recovery from an ACL rupture. His imminent link-up with Andrews, Starcevich and Payne spells problems for opposing attacks.

Interspersed between are the speedy likes of McKenna and Wilmot, as well as veterans in Zorko and Lester, providing Chris Fagan with a smorgasbord of options behind the ball.

 

GEELONG, AUSTRALIA - APRIL 08: Harris Andrews of the Lions spoils a mark by Tom Hawkins of the Cats during the round four AFL match between the Geelong Cats and the Brisbane Lions at GMHBA Stadium on April 08, 2022 in Geelong, Australia. (Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

 

Published by
Zero Hanger