In an era where dynamic small-medium backmen are more valuable than ever, the success of AFL teams continues to be shaped in part by the versatility and impact of intercepting and rebounding defenders.
As we look ahead to the 2025 season, it's time to rank the top 10 general defenders, focusing on those who excel at intercepting, offensive transition and crucial lockdown roles.
This list is not just about pure stats but also considers overall impact, versatility and the ability to influence games from the backline.
From All-Australian mainstays to rising stars, these defenders have proven their worth, with each player bringing a unique skill set to their team's defensive unit.
Before we dive in, a few notable snubs warrant mention, reflecting just how deep the pool of backline talent is heading into the new season.
Snubs
- Bailey Dale
- Nic Martin
- Sam Flanders
- Adam Saad
- Mitchell Hinge
- Connor Idun
- Daniel Rioli
- Nic Newman
- Andrew McGrath
- Wil Powell
- Jordan Clark
- Blake Hardwick
- Zach Guthrie
- Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera
*Positions based on Champion Data's 'general defender' qualifications.
3. Jack Sinclair
Jack Sinclair has firmly established himself as St Kilda's best player over the past three seasons, with two best & fairest awards and back-to-back All-Australian selections in 2022 and 2023.
Though 2024 marked a slight regression in his performance, it's hard to ignore the Saints' disappointing season as a contributing factor, missing finals after finishing sixth the previous year.
Sinclair was often deployed by Ross Lyon in various roles across the backline and midfield, which, while showcasing his versatility, may have impacted his natural flow and rhythm on the field.
Despite the shifts, Sinclair's elite ball use and decision-making remained evident, especially toward the end of the season when he reaffirmed his status as one of the AFL's most reliable and precise ball movers.
Now 29, Sinclair enters a pivotal stage in his career, potentially with three prime seasons left to help guide the Saints' emerging talents.
His role as a mentor and on-field leader will be invaluable as St Kilda looks to re-enter finals contention, hoping Sinclair's experience can steer the team toward success.
