In an era where dynamic small-medium backmen are more valuable than ever, the success of AFL teams continues to be shaped in part by the versatility and impact of intercepting and rebounding defenders.
As we look ahead to the 2025 season, it's time to rank the top 10 general defenders, focusing on those who excel at intercepting, offensive transition and crucial lockdown roles.
This list is not just about pure stats but also considers overall impact, versatility and the ability to influence games from the backline.
From All-Australian mainstays to rising stars, these defenders have proven their worth, with each player bringing a unique skill set to their team's defensive unit.
Before we dive in, a few notable snubs warrant mention, reflecting just how deep the pool of backline talent is heading into the new season.
Snubs
- Bailey Dale
- Nic Martin
- Sam Flanders
- Adam Saad
- Mitchell Hinge
- Connor Idun
- Daniel Rioli
- Nic Newman
- Andrew McGrath
- Wil Powell
- Jordan Clark
- Blake Hardwick
- Zach Guthrie
- Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera
*Positions based on Champion Data's 'general defender' qualifications.
1. Tom Stewart
Tom Stewart's status as the best general defender in the AFL is hard to dispute after another brilliant 2024 season. Stewart is a five-time All-Australian, widely recognised for his elite intercept marking, precise ball use, and unmatched ability to read the play.
In 2024, Stewart showcased his exceptional consistency once again, leading Geelong's backline in yet another top four finish and deep finals run.
His intercept work remains unparalleled, often cutting off opposition attacks before they develop.
At 31, Stewart still plays with a hunger and sharpness that belies his age, maintaining his reputation as one of the league's most reliable and influential defenders.
In crucial moments, Stewart's composure under pressure and leadership shine through, often directing traffic and setting up the Cats' rebound play.
As the backbone of Geelong's defence, his blend of athleticism, experience and on-field IQ cements him as the top general defender in the competition heading into 2025.
